There are a few rather sharp minds on this website(genuine intellectual heavyweights) and I've had the fantastic chance to read their deep discourses on which constitutes a border. How with no edge one is trading using negative expectancy, etc.etc.
Assuming level playing areas (no insider information),IMHO a border is nothing more than the ability to recognise recurring patterns on the marketplace. I believe money management and pattern recognition would be as good an edge as you can hope for.
I'm starting this journal for my live trades with what I believe is my edge.
I will be trading Cable on intraday basis. I will risk 2% or less per trade.
I use no indiors to enter or depart my transactions. I do use Pitchforks and Fib Retracements to analyse the marketplace.
Starting amount $150K

Please notice the aim of this thread isn't to argue the relative merits of my own beliefs.
Z